Massive wave of pardoned cases?

Comment below rating threshold, click here to show it.

meadow

Senior Member

01-29-2013

http://na.leagueoflegends.com/tribunal/case/6159903/
Game 1: Kassadin [00:01:32] stfu
Game 4: Singed [00:21:05] ur dumb
Game 5: Eleven deaths and arguing, although there were his team mates who also verbally abused him.

http://na.leagueoflegends.com/tribunal/case/6162164/
Game 1: It didn't seem the ADC cared for constructive feedback at all and seems to care more about attempting to convince people reporting Alistar instead of helping him.
Tristana [00:05:18] wow alistar
Tristana [00:05:21] so bad
Tristana [00:06:50] noob
Tristana [All] [00:08:04] report ali please
Tristana [All] [00:15:27] repott all team please
Tristana [All] [00:25:11] report alistar please
Tristana [00:28:23] WOrst alistar ever
Tristana [All] [00:28:30] report alistar please
Game 2: Also the same "report, report, report"
Game 3: Sion [00:12:44] trynda you suck dude
Game 4: Seems like he just repeats its "report trend"
Darius [All] [00:16:37] my team =8
Darius [All] [00:16:39] sucks

http://na.leagueoflegends.com/tribunal/case/6162358/
Game 3:
Ryze [00:29:44] omfg!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! stop sucking a pair of c*ckss and quit
Ryze [00:32:11] im afk so surender
Ryze [00:32:37] ff*cking click yes
Ryze [00:33:05] surrender
Ryze [00:33:22] ty b*tches
Game 4:
Shaco [00:03:40] OMFG LEAVE B*TTCH
Game 5:
Ryze [All] [00:15:09] sry u suck lol

http://na.leagueoflegends.com/tribunal/case/6162449/
Game 2: Calling his own team "noob" and "dumb"
Game 3: Nasus [00:01:33] dumbass (Only one thing in this game but meh).
Game 4: Teemo [00:19:16] dumb jungler (It seems this reported person likes the word "dumb".)

http://na.leagueoflegends.com/tribunal/case/6164015/
Game 2: Apparently left the game after getting killed twice.
Game 5: Morgana [00:10:22] stfu then
Morgana [00:10:48] nub
Morgana [00:10:50] get ownedmidmore
Morgana [00:11:19] lmao
Morgana [00:11:21] lmao
Morgana [00:11:23] lmao
Morgana [00:22:08] all u had to do was stfu
Morgana [00:27:51] thats why we need to stfu and play

http://na.leagueoflegends.com/tribunal/case/6164524/ Seems this one is most toxic so far.
Game 2:Galio [All] [00:31:42] you got fat, kid
Galio [00:32:04] im done after this
Game 3: Ahri [00:10:07] and shes a f*cking b*tch
Ahri [00:30:56] you didnt f*cking do sh*t
Ahri [00:31:50] why wont you f*cking surrender
Game 5: Miss Fortune [00:15:07] you didnt use one f*cking cd karma
Miss Fortune [00:15:12] god damn i hate useless supports
Miss Fortune [00:15:28] you did f*ck all
Miss Fortune [All] [00:15:57] report karma for feeding please. (Karma had two deaths as support, clearly not report-worthy)
Miss Fortune [00:16:12] go f*ck off now kk?
Miss Fortune [All] [00:18:50] smurf your sh*t elo?
Miss Fortune [All] [00:19:18] like i said, i was giving tips, you got lippy, so now you get the *sshole

http://na.leagueoflegends.com/tribunal/case/6164715/
Seems this case from Game 1-4 is only about repeatedly saying "reporting [player]" in either /all or team chat and although game 5 was slightly aggressive did not verbally abused his own team. This game would be a "pardon" on borderline.

http://na.leagueoflegends.com/tribunal/case/6165526/
Game 2:
Darius [00:01:44] stf*
Darius [00:01:49] not after calling me a nub
Darius [00:05:03] stop auto attacking kid
Darius [00:05:55] just go bot kid
Game 3: Apparently abused the report button if he did by reporting the enemy team.
Kha'Zix [00:26:03] **** off
Game 4: I remember that there was text stating that this player left the game, but it isn't there anymore.
Game 5: Although he has the right to report when verbally abused, retaliating on them is not okay.
Nocturne [All] [00:05:24] reported
Nocturne [All] [00:05:26] nerd
Nocturne [All] [00:05:29]
Nocturne [All] [00:10:33] noob
Nocturne [00:15:00] this kid is so gay (Seriously, what has being "gay" anything to do with a video game?)
Nocturne [00:32:30] what you want me to do noob

http://na.leagueoflegends.com/tribunal/case/6166139/
Game 1:
Jayce [00:20:56] this adc suckks
Jayce [00:23:19] LEO STF*!
Jayce [00:23:38] ours is retarded
Jayce [00:36:01] i told u stupid as f*ckl
Jayce [All] [00:40:48] our bot lane *******d
Game 3: Ezreal [00:24:52] going afk
Ezreal [All] [00:25:12] report me going afk
Game 5: Seems he was trolling with AP runes.
Graves [00:14:19] skarner are u stupid
Graves [All] [00:15:31] omfg these kids
Graves [All] [00:21:49] f*ccking idoit doesnt understand
Graves [All] [00:24:21] U F*UCCKING IDOTI

9 cases consecutively pardoned in one gigantic go?!
Exception that this screwed up my entire Justice Rating, it saddens me greatly that Toxic Players manage to escape definite judgement.

Edit: Offensive words has been slightly filtered with *.


Comment below rating threshold, click here to show it.

Shiister

This user has referred a friend to League of Legends, click for more information

Senior Member

01-29-2013

Pardon trolls.

Guess with Tribunal being down the regular voters didn't vote on the same cases as you, but the pardon trolls did and some of your cases got pardon. Give it a few days and pardons like that won't happen.


Comment below rating threshold, click here to show it.

meadow

Senior Member

01-29-2013

I'm working through the cases as why it should've deserved a punish still for clarity, thanks for your input Shiister, I was already like "Huh, why does this deserves a pardon?!"


Comment below rating threshold, click here to show it.

Shiister

This user has referred a friend to League of Legends, click for more information

Senior Member

01-29-2013

Quote:
Originally Posted by meadow View Post
I'm working through the cases as why it should've deserved a punish still for clarity, thanks for your input Shiister, I was already like "Huh, why does this deserves a pardon?!"
Most cases that have a "Strong Majority" pardon are usually trolls who spam pardon in Tribunal. If someone really does deserve pardon they are usually Overwhelming.


Comment below rating threshold, click here to show it.

meadow

Senior Member

01-29-2013

Alright, I'm done reviewing all the pardoned suspecious cases and it seems only ONE is borderline pardonable while the rest is toxic as hell >_<

I've sent a ticket to support in the hope that these cases be reviewed again.


Comment below rating threshold, click here to show it.

170 Calories

Senior Member

01-29-2013

Case # Your Vote Community Agreement Outcome
6165930 Skip - Pardon
6164749 Pardon Overwhelming Majority Pardon
6164357 Pardon Overwhelming Majority Pardon
6163281 Skip - Pardon
6162766 Punish Almost No One Pardon
6162757 Punish Minority Pardon
6161502 Punish Minority Pardon
6161188 Punish Minority Pardon
6161107 Punish Minority Pardon

Same for me as well.


Comment below rating threshold, click here to show it.

Celticnate123

Junior Member

01-29-2013

This gets a pardon yet my 2 week ban for saying gg noobs gets majority ban. Tribunal totally works.


Comment below rating threshold, click here to show it.

xystris

Senior Member

01-29-2013

i don't seem to have a problem but the cases I've been reviewing has alot more games (usually 5 now) and it's harder to click punish when 2-3 games are not bannable with 1-2 borderline.


Comment below rating threshold, click here to show it.

meadow

Senior Member

01-29-2013

Quote:
Originally Posted by xystris View Post
i don't seem to have a problem but the cases I've been reviewing has alot more games (usually 5 now) and it's harder to click punish when 2-3 games are not bannable with 1-2 borderline.
That would be a pardon though, these cases exception one are all definely punish.


Comment below rating threshold, click here to show it.

xystris

Senior Member

01-29-2013

Quote:
Originally Posted by meadow View Post
That would be a pardon though, these cases exception one are all definely punish.
not really. I would skip some of the games your listed and all my skips are pardoned...