Minion damage debate. Clarification would be nice.

Maulkrieg

Senior Member

A friend says that pro streamers said "You take no damage from melee minions, so it allows your harass to be amazing early game." He specifically mentioned Kayle.

I say that they weren't being literal; that it was a simple hyperbole. He insists they were being literal. I told him that its mathematically impossible to take zero damage from minions at the start of the game. My proof being this:

Kayle starts with 20.5 armor at level 1.

Doran's Shield was specifically mentioned for letting you harass and take "no minion damage" with the right masteries. Including runes and masteries, you would have 20.5+13+10+6(-4 minion damage).That's 50 armor if you round up, which is .66666667 damage from AD.

Melee minions have 12 (+1/3 per min) AD. I won't even include how they will have 13 AD by the time they get to you, and 14 by the time your harass becomes a threat.
(12-4)*.6666667=5.333336.
However, if the system works contrary to normal flat reductions in the math, it would still be 12*.6666667-4=4.

Again, I mentioned, streamers were not being literal, as HP regen may make it so you take a net of 0 damage from melee minions in trades.

I do not see how I can logically be wrong without a bug in the system. So, please clarify if the actual results are different than the theory.

TL;DR You always take damage from minions, possibly with the exception of Amumu or Sion, unless there is a bug.

Skilltestingman

Senior Member

Ok um, u have to understand that it wasn't literal. I don't even see how u don't see it.

It's impossible to take no damage. Because of the small damage u take plus health regen, you can feel comfortable staying in lane

Mageinta Warrior

Senior Member

Actually, I play Singed top and take zero damage from melee minions around lvl 9. Like, you see zeroes popping up above my head. I think the masteries are applied post calculation.

Nesious

Senior Member

Masteries that reduce damage taken by a flat amount (Minion Damage reduction and Indomitable) Along with high amounts of armor or Amumu' passive on his E can potentially make it so that you take zero damage from minions, but not from armor itself.