24 ap vs 6 Mpen

Comment below rating threshold, click here to show it.

HeXiiS

Senior Member

05-13-2011

3 x 7.8 Ap/lvl quints
or
3 x 2.8 magic pen quints

which would benefit more, around mid game, during team fights?

(obviously Mpen is better early game)


i have Mpen reds and AP blues


Comment below rating threshold, click here to show it.

Medusa

Senior Member

05-13-2011

Depends what champ it is on and what are the ratios of the skills.

AP better on Support, M-pen on DPS/Nukers.


Comment below rating threshold, click here to show it.

HeXiiS

Senior Member

05-13-2011

i play akali, vlad, sometimes karthus


Comment below rating threshold, click here to show it.

Medusa

Senior Member

05-13-2011

AP possibly on Akali to trigger her passive early (depending what your starting item is) but M-pen on Vlad and Karth.


Comment below rating threshold, click here to show it.

Arbitrarity

Senior Member

05-13-2011

Numbers are off. Mpen quints give 1.89 pen. Anyways, calculation is simply (base damage + ratio*(base AP+quint value))*100/(100+(enemy MR-other pen-Quint pen)). So if we stick some arbitrary numbers in there, like say, Vlad's Q at level 12, (100 AP, sorc shoes, enemy has 50 MR) we get (250+ 0.6(100+17))*100/(100+(50-28)) vs (250+0.6(100))*100/(100+(50-34)), or 262.5 vs 267.2.
In that case, Mpen is favored.
Keep in mind MPen is better early game than scaling AP, since you don't have maximum penetration without sorc shoes. Mpen scales much worse if enemies begin getting significant amounts of MR, but is stronger against enemies with little MR.

As Akali, you might consider Potency quints (flat AP) since they are stronger than the scaling up till 11 or so, and can help activate your double passives at level 1.


Comment below rating threshold, click here to show it.

bARRtender

This user has referred a friend to League of Legends, click for more information

Senior Member

05-13-2011

Quote:
Originally Posted by Anivias Chosen View Post
AP possibly on Akali to trigger her passive early (depending what your starting item is) but M-pen on Vlad and Karth.
I agree with this.

To actually do the math you can figure it out yourself. Predict the amount of mRes the opponents will have and what level you are, take these formulas and do some simple math:
3 x 7.8 Ap/lvl quints
([spell dmg] + ([expected ap]+23.4*[ap ratio]) * 100/([expected mRes]+100)
or
3 x 2.8 magic pen quints
([spell dmg] + ([expected ap]*[ap ratio]) * 100/([expected mRes]-8.4+100)

I'm going to bet that magic pen wins.

Edit: idk why I filled out half the equations but not the other half. Now it's just variables.


Comment below rating threshold, click here to show it.

HeXiiS

Senior Member

05-13-2011

thanks for the responses guys