World Playoffs - Rule Violations

First Riot Post
Comment below rating threshold, click here to show it.

Xenodyne

Senior Member

10-10-2012

Quote:
Originally Posted by bitingpig View Post
League of Legends Competition Ruling

Tournament: World Playoffs, Quarterfinal #3, Game 1
Teams: Azubu Frost vs. TSM
Date of Match: October 5
Date of Ruling: October 9
Subject: Unsportsmanlike Conduct


Chronology:

The game was paused to deal with audio/microphone malfunctions with the AzF headsets. During the pause:
  • TSM Chaox said that he had witnessed a member of AzF looking at the venue screens during the game. Referees didnít independently corroborate these allegations.
  • TSM Dyrus looked back and up at the venue screens.

The match was then restarted as a result of AzFís inability to fully communicate in-game (mic malfunction). Prior to the restart, referees directed both teams to look forward at all times during the match.

After the restart, TSM left its base en masse, appearing to be invading top lane/brush. At 00:15 on the game clock, Woong of AzF looked back and up to his right at the venue screens.At 00:25 on the game clock, an AzF player pinged near the lane between TSMís top inhibitor tower and the second top lane tower.

AzF Shy (Jayce) and AzF MadLife (Blitzcrank) headed to top lane. AzF Shy (Jayce) approached the brush where TSM was headed to hide, switched to Cannon mode and fired his skillshot into the brush, landing a hit on TSM Dyrus (Darius), which gave away TSM Dyrus (Darius)í position. AzF Shy (Jayce) then backed away.

Once AzF had confirmed that Darius was top lane with Jayceís skillshot:
  • AzF sent two players deep into TSMís red jungle to drop a sapling at wraith camp, which would ordinarily be a dangerous risk for only two players.
  • AzF Woong (Miss Fortune) facechecked bottom laneís tribrush, which would have been an extremely risky move had he not known that the lane was likely unoccupied by TSM. AzF Woong (Miss Fortune) did not even cast ďMake it RainĒ to reveal the brush, indicating a high level of confidence that the brush was uncontested.


Relevant Competition Rule(s):

1. The World Championship Competition Rules, Paragraph 9.1, prohibit unsportsmanlike behavior.
a. Penalties, as set forth in Paragraph 9.2, include, without limitation:
i. Verbal Warning
ii. Prize Money Deduction
1. Minor infraction: 5% of World Championship prize money
2. Major infraction: 20% of World Championship prize money
iii. Loss of Side Selection
iv. Game Forfeiture
v. Tournament Disqualification
2. Prior to the game, referees directed both teams to look forward at all times during the match.


Analysis:

TSM Dyrus clearly turned his head to his left and looked back and upward at the venue screen, but there is no direct evidence that TSM Dyrus obtained any helpful information from this action. TSM obtained no direct meaningful benefits from TSM Dyrusí action; the game was restarted afterward.

TSM Chaox briefly turned his head toward the AzF team to monitor them. This violation had no potential or actual gameplay benefits for TSM.

AzF Woong clearly turned his head to his right and looked back and upward at the venue screens. The potential gains from this action were not inconsequential. At 00:15 into the restarted game, AzF had no idea where TSM was located or which direction they were headed. AzF did not have Clairvoyance. By looking at the venue screens, AzF Woong stood to learn the location of all TSM champions.AzF Woongís actions did yield tangible benefits for AzF. Once AzF learned that all five members of TSM were in the top lane area, this reduced TSMís ability to control top lane and pressure AzFís blue side. It also allowed AzF to more safely invade TSMís red side.


Rulings:

TSM Chaox did not look forward at all times during the game. This was not unsportsmanlike conduct.

TSM Dyrus violated the rules by looking at the stage screens. This violation, however, did not yield any meaningful benefits for TSM.

AzF Woong violated the rules by looking at the stage screens. His actions yielded benefits for AzF in the game. Other members of AzF modified their gameplay based upon the information.


Penalties:

TSM Chaox: None.

TSM Dyrus is hereby warned not to engage in any further rule violations. Further violations may result in additional penalties.

AzF Woong committed a major infraction of the rules and the team is hereby collectively fined in the amount of 20% of the prize winnings earned by AzF as a result of advancing into the Semifinals ($150,000). AzFís total fine for this violation is $30,000. Further violations may result in additional penalties.
On top of a fine, they should be thrown out of the tournament, and the match reversed. If you guys actually want to make this a sport, punish just like any sport would for cheating. You throw the entire team out for the one member who was cheating. Had AzF not spotted them at level one, they may have made a mistake and fallen for TSM's trap.

$30,000 is nothing if they've been allowed to continue in the tournament. Even if they get beat out, TSM got denied their top spot in part due to cheating. Who's to say that there wasn't more cheating than that happening? Where there's smoke there's fire, etc.


Comment below rating threshold, click here to show it.

IvI 100 Bidoof

This user has referred a friend to League of Legends, click for more information

Senior Member

10-10-2012

fine korean team 30k -> donate money to korea
ok


Comment below rating threshold, click here to show it.

cwazypwepsi

This user has referred a friend to League of Legends, click for more information

Senior Member

10-10-2012

lol


Comment below rating threshold, click here to show it.

Vdo

Senior Member

10-10-2012

I definitely think AZF shouldn't be put off so lightly but you also have to consider this shouldn't have happened in the first place..as Riot designed the stage poorly. Therefore you can't 100% blame AZF, although it is still horrible sportsmanship.


Comment below rating threshold, click here to show it.

merkenberry

Senior Member

10-10-2012

this is not justice and the logic behind the sanctions are a joke. it's about cheating or not cheating, not how much benefit was reaped from the cheating. of course it's just as much riot's ineptitude for making it so ridiculously easy to the point they can reasonably be charged with aiding and abetting.


Comment below rating threshold, click here to show it.

Itsvadertime

Junior Member

10-10-2012

GUYS.....You must not have realized but that same team who cheated is currently playing and still in the tournament. I'm sure that's a mistake because a legitimate company like yours would never actually let a team who gets caught cheating red handed and taking an advantage from it have a chance at holding the world champion title. Just wanted to let you guys know.


Comment below rating threshold, click here to show it.

Vayumad

Senior Member

10-10-2012

Oh you cheated? 30k off winnings! Gee! Out of 1 millions dollars that sure is alot!


Comment below rating threshold, click here to show it.

merkenberry

Senior Member

10-10-2012

Quote:
Originally Posted by Itsvadertime View Post
GUYS.....You must not have realized but that same team who cheated is currently playing and still in the tournament. I'm sure that's a mistake because a legitimate company like yours would never actually let a team who gets caught cheating red handed and taking an advantage from it have a chance at holding the world champion title. Just wanted to let you guys know.
they're in the finals. and yeah, this is a complete farce. Are they afraid of disqualifying the last Korean team left in fear of losing market shares there or is their sense of justice really that warped?


Comment below rating threshold, click here to show it.

ReDragn

Junior Member

10-10-2012

its ok cheat and we will still let u go for a million dollars cuz we r too scared to dq u


Comment below rating threshold, click here to show it.

SwingOutSoul

Junior Member

10-10-2012

riot ruin tourney by theirselves .