Welcome to the Forum Archive!

Years of conversation fill a ton of digital pages, and we've kept all of it accessible to browse or copy over. Whether you're looking for reveal articles for older champions, or the first time that Rammus rolled into an "OK" thread, or anything in between, you can find it here. When you're finished, check out the boards to join in the latest League of Legends discussions.

GO TO BOARDS


Vayne Sona and Poppy,

Comment below rating threshold, click here to show it.

Wiseman Silo

Senior Member

11-04-2011

A lot of people keep grouping them up with the REAL demacians.

Xin
Jarvan
Galio
Garen
Shyvana
Lux

THOSE are the only demacians. Sona is from Ionia and only lives in Demacia and from the looks of her lore doesnt spend much time there. Vayne has no assosiation with the city state other then living there.

Poppy is an AMBASSADOR so by her very nature isn't demacian she's from bandle city like most other w/e the heck she is.

Its the difference bettween Representing the city state and just living there.

Blitzcrank
Janna
Twisted Fate

All 3 from Zuan but none represent it. Its the same thing.


Comment below rating threshold, click here to show it.

Pikeh

Senior Member

11-04-2011

Wasn't xin a noxian gladiator?


Comment below rating threshold, click here to show it.

freAK47

Senior Member

11-04-2011

yes but he was excepted into demacia because he took an arrow for their king when he didnt need to.

and twisted fate isnt from zaun, hes from demacia. im not sure who he fights for.


Comment below rating threshold, click here to show it.

Summoner Abyss

Senior Member

11-04-2011

Vayne even though she travels around she still a demancain citizen.


Comment below rating threshold, click here to show it.

TheNarvalOfDeath

Senior Member

11-04-2011

Vayne is a demacian noble as far as i know.
But she isnt well recieved there because of his way of handling "justice" which is not really demacian (you know, going around in the dark killing evil beasts without the spinning and stuff)


Comment below rating threshold, click here to show it.

Wiseman Silo

Senior Member

11-04-2011

Quote:
Summoner Abyss:
Vayne even though she travels around she still a demancain citizen.


Thats the point i'm trying to make. Citizen and City-State Rep are two different things

Like I said with Zuan a lot of people come from or hang around Zuan but only mundo, singed and WW fight for Zuan.

Look at Noxus too Their City state reps are
Cassiopia
Katarina
Swain (Debatable)
Talon
Urgot
Riven (Debatable)
Sion

BUT these guys all just LIVE there.
Mordekaiser
Leblanc (Works with Swain not Noxus)
Vladamir (Vlad only joined to kill it says it in his spotlight I really don't think it matters that he was selected to fight for Noxus in the Noxus vs Ionia battle so was Rammus and he definitly is neutral)
Morgana (Apparently lives in Noxus but works in Zuan gotta be an awful commute)

Out of the three Poppy, Vayne, and Sona. Poppy is the closest to being an actual Demacian rep but she's still shown in more Bandle City storyline art then Demacian. AND an Ambassador usually isn't from the place she's being diplomatic to.

Vayne is just a vigilante something i'd have to assume is actually against the law in demacia regardless she is not a representative of Demacia she just lives there.

Sona dispite being from Ionia and living in Demacia would probably be more loyal to Noxus only because her band Pentakill seems to mostly hang around Noxus and i'd assume it's her primary fanbase. Still she's definitly Neutral.


Comment below rating threshold, click here to show it.

1Eredale

Senior Member

11-04-2011

I say this is discrimination towards immigrants, xenophobia or some****. Why not just let it go and feel ok when someone says Sona or Poppy is Demacian?


Comment below rating threshold, click here to show it.

Valkyrea

Senior Member

11-04-2011

Vayne was born in Demacia , this makes her demacian in my books


Comment below rating threshold, click here to show it.

Wiseman Silo

Senior Member

11-06-2011

Quote:
xSleepingDragonx:
Vayne was born in Demacia , this makes her demacian in my books


I'm not talking about being born demacian. I'm talking about being afiliated with the military.

When someone says "The Demacians" They are 99% talking about the City-State Representatives. Vayne, Sona, and Poppy get pulled into being thought of as reps because of their affiliation with Demacia BUT they are only residents.

Blitzcrank is technicly from Zuan but is clearly not affiliated with them.


Comment below rating threshold, click here to show it.

AugustoTDR

Recruiter

11-06-2011

Quote:
Wiseman Silo:
I'm not talking about being born demacian. I'm talking about being afiliated with the military.

When someone says "The Demacians" They are 99% talking about the City-State Representatives. Vayne, Sona, and Poppy get pulled into being thought of as reps because of their affiliation with Demacia BUT they are only residents.

Blitzcrank is technicly from Zuan but is clearly not affiliated with them.


So for example, Dr. Mundo doesn't represent Zaun given he's not affiliated with their military corps?