Isomalt's Baked Goods Tier List

First Riot Post
1234511 ... 47
Comment below rating threshold, click here to show it.

Isomalt

Senior Member

05-21-2010

This list represents my personal opinion of how delicious I feel specific Baked Goods are in, uh... eating scenarios. The reasoning behind Baked Good placement on this list is how delicious a certain Baked Good will increase your taste buds chances of making you happy. I feel higher tier Baked Goods correspond to a better chance at victory.

I have over 200,000 Baked Goods made and 1200 recipes, because of my practical experience I feel this list is fairly accurate.

If you want an explanation for Baked Good placement please ask.

UPDATED 5/28/2010

Cookies
God Tier:
Chocolate Chip Cookies
Tier
1:, Gingersnaps, Oatmeal Raisin Cookie
Tier 2:
Biscotti, Macaroons (French), Macaroons (Coconut), Snickerdoodles
Tier 3:
Linzer Cookies, Madeleine, Lemon Bars
Tier 4:
Rugelach, Tuiles, Shortbread, Plamiers
Tier 5:
Pecan Sandies
Tier 6:
Granola Bars

Cakes
God Tier:
Cheesecake-Brownies
Tier 1: Brownies,Cheesecake, Red Velvet Cake, Carrot (w/ Cream cheese frosting of course)
Tier 2: Cupcakes, Chocolate Cake, Molten Chocolate Cake, Some sort of crazy ass ice cream cake w/ cake on the outside baked using some yet to be invented technology
Tier 3: Coffee Cake, Tiramisu, Tres Leches (w/ Rum)
Tier 4: Angel Food Cake, Yule Logs, Short Cake, Wedding Cake
Tier 5: Pound Cake
Tier 6: Fruit Cake, Orange Chiffon Cake

Pies
God Tier: Cherry
Tier 1: Chocolate Tortes, Tart Tatin
Tier 2:
Peach Cobbler, Pumpkin, Pecan, Chocolate Mousse
Tier 3:
Apple, Raspberry, Strawberry Rhubarb, Blueberry
Tier 4:
Fruit Tarts
Tier 5:
, Lemon Meringue, Peanut Butter,
Tier 6:
Almond Torte, Grape (wtf is this?)

Other
God Tier:
Creme Brulee
Tier 1: Profiteroles, Eclairs, Pot de Creme, Brioche Pudding, Chocolate Souffles, Sticky Buns(Cinnamon Buns)
Tier 2:
Danish, Apple Crisp, Baklava, Chocolate Croissants, Muffins
Tier 3: Apple Brown Betty, Cream Puffs, Fruit Souffles, Napoleans, Strudel
Tier 4:
Brioche, Croissant, Scones
Tier 5:
Meringue, Melon Bread, Fruit based Souffle
Tier 6:
Sticky Date Pudding


I feel tier 1,2, and 3 Baked Goods are strong. Tier 4 Baked Goods are decent but could use slight buffs. Tier 5 Baked Goods are down right terrible. I cry if i see a tier 6 Baked Good on my plate.

*Scones - extremely strong early morning but most often offers 0 flavor to team comp of coffee and pastry.

*Yule Logs - haven't seen this much in except around christmas because of the the seasonal to this. This placement may change w/ in a couple of months.

*Cheesecake Bumped down to Tier 1 in Favor of Cheesecake brownies, which have recently been found to be overwhelmingly OP.

Alot of these Baked Goods' placement is due to the fact that chocolate is so strong in the Baked Goods world right now. I feel the majority of this list also revolves around baked goods ability to burst, and contrast in texture/temperature. Also this list is representative of High Class Dining.


Still waiting on the new patch which will hopefully nerf Chocolate being in every high tiered dessert.


-Isomalt


Edit: Updated List/Reformatted.


Comment below rating threshold, click here to show it.

Profeta

Member

05-21-2010

Isomalt, thats so great!


Comment below rating threshold, click here to show it.

Nazzet

Senior Member

05-21-2010

I'm sorry, I laughed


Comment below rating threshold, click here to show it.

Pendragon

Director of Player Experience

Follow RiotPendragon on Twitter

05-21-2010
1 of 47 Riot Posts

IMHO Macaroons should be tier 2, pretty good list otherwise


Comment below rating threshold, click here to show it.

xSugahBear

Junior Member

05-21-2010

Yule logs remind me of something else


Comment below rating threshold, click here to show it.

Saruyan

Senior Member

05-21-2010

im sorry but granola should obviously move up a rank. putting it on the same tier as fruit cake? come on. even for top 100 diners thats just insulting.


Comment below rating threshold, click here to show it.

Eppa

Senior Member

05-21-2010

chocolate chip cookie isn't that good once you eat a couple of times. Where is my **** black and white suffle it like chocolate ^2?


Comment below rating threshold, click here to show it.

TaigaStance

This user has referred a friend to League of Legends, click for more information

Recruiter

05-21-2010

Shortbread should be added.

And I personally feel that Apple Crisp should be higher tier.


Comment below rating threshold, click here to show it.

Phreak

Shoutcaster

05-21-2010
2 of 47 Riot Posts

This man is a gentleman and a scholar.

Also, Cheesecake needs its own tier. Cherry pie should be at/above apple pie.


Comment below rating threshold, click here to show it.

Loote

Oceanic Project Manager

05-21-2010
3 of 47 Riot Posts

I disagree, I think that Fruit Cake and Granola are definitely at the bottom tier.

However, Red Velvet Cake should be tier 1, no other cakes can even compare.


1234511 ... 47